Zillman's NRL biting appeal dismissed - Sports News - Fanatics - the world's biggest events

Zillman's NRL biting appeal dismissed

By Ian McCullough 21/08/2009 06:11:45 PM Comments (0)

Gold Coast Titans fullback William Zillman has had his appeal against a four-match suspension for biting South Sydney winger Jamie Simpson dismissed by NRL Judiciary chairman Robert Abood.

Zillman was charged with dangerous conduct and had his case referred directly to the judiciary who handed down the suspension on Wednesday.

Zillman's defence council, led by barrister Geoff Bellew, lodged an appeal against the guilty verdict and the ban following the incident which took place in the Titans' 22-12 win over Souths last Friday.

However, Abood upheld the ruling imposed by the three-man judiciary panel of Mark Coyne, Bob Lindner and Sean Garlick.

"As to the granting of leave to appeal, Rule 95(2) of the National Rugby League Judiciary Code provides that the Chairman shall not grant leave to appeal unless he is of the opinion it is a fit case to proceed as an appeal within the meaning of that expression as it is defined in Rule 27 of the NRL Appeals Committee Procedural Rules," Abood said in a statement.

"Under Rule 27(1) the expression fit case to proceed shall be taken to mean that the case is one in respect of which the appellant has good prospects of success on the hearing of that appeal.

"In this regard, I agree with both Counsel, that the term does not require me, as chairman, to be satisfied that the appeal will succeed.

"Taking all of those matters into account, I am not of the view that given the nature of the offence found proved, that the penalty is not excessive and conclude that any appeal against the severity of that penalty would not have good prospects of success."

Titans managing director Michael Searle said the club was disappointed in the decision but considered the matter closed.

"While we are disappointed we were unsuccessful in convincing the chairman of the need to grant an appeal, we acknowledge that the process has allowed the club the chance to do so," said Searle.

"We stand firm in our support of William and his continued protest of innocence.

"However, we now consider the matter closed."

Brought to you by AAP AAP © 2022 AAP

0 Comments about this article

Post a comment about this article

Please sign in to leave a comment.
Becoming a member is free and easy, sign up here.

« All sports news